Why Did Jesus Say “My God, Why Have You Forsaken Me”?

why did jesus say my god why have you forsaken me

#1 Trending /

238

Why Did Jesus Say “My God, Why Have You Forsaken Me”?

11 min read    
2 months ago
Sound Of Heaven

Johnny Ova

35 Likes

54 Comment

24 Share

We come to the cross carrying a deep question about loss, pain, and divine presence. In that darkest hour, the words on Jesus’ lips echo Psalm 22 and point us to a larger story of trust that moves toward healing.

We read this scene with a New Covenant lens: the cry is not proof of abandonment but an invitation to see the Father’s heart. The historical details in Matthew and Mark tie the cross to the Psalm’s lament and its rise to praise.

As we study the question, we will name the turning point this moment creates for humanity: pain met by presence, sorrow met by restoration. Our aim is practical clarity—so believers can pray, heal, and live in the Kingdom that is already breaking in.

For a deeper study that traces Scripture and context, explore a focused reflection at this study.

Key Takeaways

  • The cry on the cross echoes Psalm 22 and fulfills Scripture.
  • We read the moment as revelation of the Father’s restoring heart.
  • Historical details in Matthew and Mark tie the scene to lament and praise.
  • This is a pastoral invitation: pain met with God’s solidarity and hope.
  • Our study seeks to equip believers with courage for everyday faith.

A cry from the cross that meets our deepest fear and reveals the Father’s heart

In that pivotal moment, a loud voice broke the silence and named the pain of the world. We stand with the people who carry long seasons of suffering; this scene places their ache in holy company.

Both Matthew and Mark report that around the ninth hour the Lord cried out the opening line of a psalm. The loud voice is not a private collapse; it is a public, pastoral proclamation that invites life back into relationship with the god father.

We read this as reason for hope: lament models honest prayer. When our life feels fractured, the god son shows us how to speak pain into communion rather than retreat from God.

“Truly this was the Son of God.”
Matthew 27:54
Moment Scripture Response
Ninth hour cry Matthew 27:46; Mark 15:34 Invitation to Psalm-shaped trust
Death and veil torn Matthew 27:51; Mark 15:38 Access to presence
Centurion’s witness Matthew 27:54 Public revelation of identity

Reading the scene: Matthew 27:46 and Mark 15:34 in their moment

When the clock marked the ninth hour, an intentional cry rose from the cross that summoned listeners to Scripture. The Gospel writers give us the hour to show the scene’s weight: darkness, public grief, and a Scripture-shaped lament.

The ninth hour: darkness, the cross, and a loud voice

Around that ninth hour the account reports that the Lord spoke aloud. The detail of time underlines the scene as historical and prophetic; it frames suffering and agony within God’s plan.

“Eli, Eli, lema sabachthani”: language, translation, and why a loud voice matters

The Aramaic phrase anchors the cry in Psalm 22. Quoting the opening line summons the whole psalm, turning a single verse into a living sermon of lament and hope.

The fact that he cried loud draws people in; some misheard and mocked, while others later recognized the meaning as signs unfolded.

From mockery to revelation: torn curtain, centurion’s confession, and what changed

After the death moment, the temple veil tore from top to bottom; a centurion confessed the Lord’s identity. Casting lots and mockery echo verses from the psalm, showing Scripture and event in concert.

Detail Scripture Significance
Ninth hour time matthew 27:46; Mark 15:34 Frames the moment as public and prophetic
Aramaic phrase “Eli, Eli, lema sabachthani” Connects the cry to Psalm 22
Torn veil & centurion matthew 27:51-54 Access opened; outsiders confess truth
Casting lots & mockery Psalm 22; Matthew 27:35-44 Fulfillment of verse after verse

We read the scene as pastoral and prophetic: lament taught publicly, and sorrow led to revelation and restored access. For a focused study on what was spoken on the cross, see what was spoken on the cross.

Why did Jesus say my god why have you forsaken me

At the cross a single cry captures a theology of suffering and a path back to hope. We hold the moment as a pastoral invitation: honest speech meets divine intent.

Common explanation: sin, wrath, and the idea the god father turned away

Many teach that the Son bore our sin and felt divine wrath as a result. Passages such as Isaiah 53, Galatians 3:13, and 2 Corinthians 5:21 inform this reading.

  • The common view: bearing sin caused perceived divine distance.
  • Some conclude this was the way God’s wrath was expressed.

A restorative reading: bearing felt distance without breaking relationship

We honor the texts while asking if the Father truly abandoned the Son. The Son entered human despair to heal it; the eternal relationship between Father and Son remains intact.

  • Jesus used Psalm words to voice human despair and point to deliverance.
  • The best answer follows the Psalm’s arc from lament to trust.

Psalm 22 in Jesus’ mouth: lament that moves to trust, despair that births praise

When the psalm’s opening line is spoken, an entire arc of sorrow and hope is summoned. That short phrase summons the larger poem and invites listeners to follow its path from complaint into confidence.

Words of the Psalm and the wounds of the Messiah

The words psalm contains vivid images that echo at the cross: mockery, piercing, and the casting of lots for garments. These details are not incidental; they fulfill verse patterns and tie the moment to Scripture.

From complaint to answered praise

The cry starts in despair and travels into praise. The psalm moves through agony and ends with a public proclamation of deliverance. This arc shows how lament can be shaped into trust even amid sin and suffering.

Scriptural literacy in the first century

Quoting the first verse signaled the whole poem. In that culture, a short phrase functioned as a summons: jesus would expect hearers to trace the full movement from question to answer.

“My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?”

The New Covenant unveiled at the cross: access, reconciliation, and the end of distance

The cross unveils a new household where barriers fall and access becomes God’s gift to the people. The torn veil signals a change: the sanctuary is open from top to bottom, and we may draw near with confidence.

The torn veil: no more barriers—God with us, God for us, God within us

The curtain tore at the moment of death, a sign from heaven that distance ended. This act shows the god father’s initiative to remove separation caused by sin. The centurion’s confession underscores that this revelation reaches the whole world.

Jesus our High Priest: once-for-all sacrifice, not eternal wrath but eternal restoration

As our god son, jesus christ serves as High Priest who finishes the part of sacrifice; it is complete and sufficient. Hebrews portrays this as a once-for-all work that opens ongoing access to life in the Spirit.

“He has made us ministers of reconciliation.”
2 Corinthians 5:18

We live in the New Covenant: prayer becomes intimate, worship becomes presence, and mission flows from grace. The psalm shows how lament can lead to praise; this verse and the torn veil knit sorrow and hope into a single story of restoration.

What this means when you may feel forsaken today

When life feels emptied of comfort, the cruciform cry gives language to our grief and a path back to hope. We meet this moment together: the Son’s vocal lament becomes our cry on behalf of all who ache.

Christ as the full image of God: if you’ve seen Him, you’ve seen the Father

We hold that looking at the Son shows the Father’s heart. The way he met pain shows the way God meets people across the earth. This means relationship, not abandonment, frames the cross.

Walking in grace: praying the lament, receiving comfort, and living reconciled

We teach simple practices: name the pain, pray the cry, and keep asking for an answer of comfort. Use Psalm 22 as words to speak until relief stirs.

  • When we may feel abandoned, his cry becomes our healing because he carried our pain on our behalf into the Father’s presence.
  • Remember the torn veil: access is open; live reconciled and forgive quickly.
  • Pray plainly: name hurt, ask boldly, wait quietly, and expect grace that restores life.
  • Act on behalf of others; our healed relationship becomes shelter for people who may feel forsaken.
“He reconciled the world to himself.”
2 Corinthians 5:19

Conclusion

The scene at the cross gathers sorrow and promise into a single, decisive moment.

At the ninth hour a loud voice quoted Psalm 22; the veil tore, and a centurion confessed the truth (matthew 27:46; Mark 15:34-39). That cry and the death jesus endured set reconciliation in motion for the world.

We hold that the god father and god son remained united while sin was borne and broken. The New Covenant is the way forward: once-for-all work that opens life and restores relationship.

Take this as an invitation: pray the phrase of lament, stay with the psalm until praise rises, and live reconciled on behalf of others. The cross has spoken; love has won—now we walk it out together.

FAQ

Why did Jesus say “My God, why have you forsaken me”?

On the cross he voiced the opening line of Psalm 22, a lament that expresses raw abandonment yet points to trust; scholars read this as the Son taking on the full experience of human estrangement from God so that restoration could be accomplished for the world. This cry matches the deep sorrow of the moment while anchoring the scene in Scripture and hope.

What does the ninth hour and the loud cry tell us about the scene?

The ninth hour marks intense darkness and suffering; his loud voice signals deliberate public speech, not a private murmur. That openness invites witnesses into the event and connects the agony to redemptive purpose—drawing the crowd, provoking confession from the centurion, and fulfilling prophetic pattern.

Why does Matthew and Mark record the Aramaic phrase and its translation?

Quoting Aramaic preserves the exact words Jesus used; offering a translation helps Greek- and Latin-speaking readers grasp the meaning. The detail underscores authenticity and makes clear that he intentionally echoed Psalm 22, inviting hearers to read the whole lament and its turn toward deliverance.

Did this cry mean the Father abandoned the Son permanently?

No; orthodox readings emphasize that the cry describes a real experience of suffering and perceived distance, not an eternal rupture in the Trinity. The cross carries divine judgment against sin while also remaining the place where God’s reconciling love is enacted and God’s purposes prevail.

How does Psalm 22 help interpret the cross moment?

Psalm 22 moves from despair to praise, describing mockery, physical wounds, and ultimate vindication. By invoking its opening, the crucified One frames his suffering within a scriptural trajectory that ends in rescue—so the lament is both honest sorrow and a pointer to God’s faithfulness.

What changed immediately after the cry—what is the significance of the torn curtain and the centurion’s confession?

The torn temple curtain symbolizes removal of barriers between people and God; the centurion’s declaration recognizes divine identity even amid suffering. Together they signal that access to God is newly opened and that the cross accomplished relational reconciliation, not merely penal transaction.

How can we understand the idea of wrath, judgment, and substitution in this moment?

One explanation emphasizes that the Son bore deserved consequences for sin, experiencing the felt reality of separation; another stresses that the event is restorative—he endures the hurt so humanity can be drawn back. Both ideas highlight different aspects of atonement: justice satisfied and relationship restored.

What does it mean for our spiritual life if we feel abandoned today?

The cross models a sacred permission to voice lament honestly while pointing to presence and comfort: Christ entered the depth of forsakenness so we need not stay there. We are invited to pray laments, receive consolation, and live in the reconciliation the cross makes real.

How should we pray or respond when we encounter suffering and apparent divine silence?

Follow the psalmist’s pattern: name the pain, call out honestly, and hold fast to God’s past faithfulness. Seek community, Scripture, and sacramental practices that remind us God is with us even when felt distance endures; such practices nurture trust and open us to restoration.

In what practical way does the New Covenant change our access to God after the cross?

The torn veil and the high-priestly work mean we approach God directly in grace; reconciliation is available, barriers are removed, and the Spirit mediates intimate relationship. Practically, this invites bold prayer, communal worship, and a life shaped by restored identity rather than ongoing estrangement.

Latest Articles