Jesus spoke about where Judas was headed before Judas ever died. That one detail answers the question, and it also clears away a cruel teaching about suicide that has wounded a lot of families.
Did Judas go to heaven? No. Jesus Himself said Judas was lost, calling him the one doomed to destruction (John 17:12), and said it would have been better for him if he had never been born (Matthew 26:24).
What decided it was his betrayal and rejection of Jesus, not the way he died. Jesus said those words while Judas was still alive. Dying by suicide does not decide anyone's eternity.
That second sentence matters as much as the first, so we say it before we open a single verse.
Maybe you lost someone to suicide, and somebody told you Judas proves where they are now. That is not what this story teaches. A believer who dies by suicide is with the Lord. Suicide does not undo what Jesus did.
If you are thinking about ending your life, please reach out right now. In the US you can call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, free and confidential, any hour. And you can talk to a pastor. Ask us to pray with you, come see us in Deer Park, or use the prayer request form at the bottom of this page.
This page is not a biography. For the man himself, read who Judas is in the Bible. For his motives, read why Judas betrayed Jesus. Here we stay with one question: where his story ended.
You will hear that Scripture is silent about Judas's fate. It is not, and the two clearest statements come from Jesus.
Spoken in prayer on the night of His arrest, after Judas had left the table. Jesus is not guessing. He is reporting.
“It would be better for him if he had not been born.” Nobody could say that about a person whose story ends in eternal life.
Praying over the empty seat, the apostles say Judas turned aside from this ministry “to go to his own place.”
Long before the betrayal, Jesus said one of the Twelve was “a devil,” and John adds that He meant Judas. Judas was drifting long before that night.
“While I was with them, I protected them and kept them safe by that name you gave me. None has been lost except the one doomed to destruction so that Scripture would be fulfilled.”
John 17:12Older translations render that phrase “the son of perdition.” It is a Semitic way of speaking. A son of something is a person marked by it, the way Jesus nicknamed James and John the sons of thunder (Mark 3:17). Judas had become a man marked by destruction, and Jesus named it out loud.
This is where the Judas question has done real damage, so we will be careful and clear.
Judas is lost because he took his own life. Suicide is the one sin you cannot repent of, so anyone who dies that way is lost too.
Jesus called Judas the one doomed to destruction while Judas was still alive. The verdict came before the death. It was about what Judas did with Jesus.
At Sound of Heaven we believe Judas perished. We say it because Jesus said it, and we would rather stand on His words than soften them. Judas made his own bed and paid the consequence. He walked with Jesus for three years, then sold Him for thirty pieces of silver and handed Him over with a kiss. Even then Jesus said, “Do what you came for, friend” (Matthew 26:50). Judas never turned back toward that friendship.
We believe just as firmly that the way he died is not what decided it. Scripture never calls suicide the unforgivable sin. The sin Jesus says will not be forgiven is hardened people calling the Spirit's work evil (Mark 3:28 to 30), as we explain in blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. A person who belongs to Jesus is held by Jesus. We teach eternal security because He did: “no one will snatch them out of my hand” (John 10:28). A believer who dies by suicide is 100 percent with the Lord.
The idea that suicide seals a person's fate gets used on the people least able to carry it: grieving parents, widows, teenagers who lost a brother. That teaching is wrong, and Judas does not support it. Judas was lost because he rejected Jesus. Peter was restored because he came back to Jesus. That is the line Scripture draws.
The strongest view on the other side deserves a fair hearing. Some sincere Christians hold out hope for Judas. He said “I have sinned,” he returned the money, and the Gospels never narrate a judgment scene. We share the heart behind that. But it cannot get around Matthew 26:24. A man who ends up with eternal life cannot be a man for whom it would have been better never to be born. Jesus knew how the story ended, and He told us.
When did Jesus call Judas “the one doomed to destruction”?
John 17:12 comes in the prayer before the garden, while Judas was alive. A verdict spoken before his death cannot be about his death.
Every post here is free to read. If this one helped you, you can help keep it that way. Pick an amount and finish on Stripe's secure checkout.
Change your amount, update your card, or cancel anytime. Enter the email you give with and Stripe sends you a secure link.
Manage My Giving"Each of you should give what you have decided in your heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver."2 Corinthians 9:7
So Judas was lost. Lost to what? Here a lot of preaching adds what the text never says.
Destruction, ruin, loss. It is the word behind “son of perdition” in John 17:12, rendered “doomed to destruction” in the NIV.
It belongs with the verb apollumi, to destroy or perish. That is the verb in John 3:16, where whoever believes “shall not perish.”
Matthew 7:13, the broad road that leads to destruction, set against the narrow road that leads to life.
A word for endless torment. The picture is a life that ends, not a life that goes on suffering.
That is why we say Gehenna instead of the medieval picture. Jesus' warnings about Gehenna are warnings about destruction. We lay out the full case in what the Bible means by Gehenna.
“For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.”
John 3:16Notice the two options Jesus sets side by side. Eternal life is a gift, and it is held in Him (see what eternal life is). The opposite of that gift is not eternal life somewhere worse. It is perishing. Judas did not receive a different kind of forever. His life faded to black, which is sobering enough.
Acts 1:25 fits the same restraint. “His own place” is understated language. Luke describes no flames or chains, only a man leaving the place Jesus gave him for the place he chose. Preachers who turn it into a vivid scene say more than Luke did.
Judas was not sentenced to suffer forever. He perished. The tragedy is what he walked away from.
Matthew tells us that when Judas saw Jesus condemned, he was seized with remorse. That line gets pulled both ways, so read it slowly. We look at that difference closely in the difference of regret and repentance.
“When Judas, who had betrayed him, saw that Jesus was condemned, he was seized with remorse and returned the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and the elders. ‘I have sinned,’ he said, ‘for I have betrayed innocent blood.’ ‘What is that to us?’ they replied. ‘That's your responsibility.’”
Matthew 27:3 to 4To regret, to feel sorry afterward. The weight falls on emotion more than on a turned will.
The same verb describes the son who changed his mind and went to work in the vineyard (Matthew 21:29). Regret can lead somewhere good.
To the chief priests, who told him it was his problem. It never went to Jesus.
The usual New Testament word is metanoeō, to think differently, a change of mind that turns a whole life around. Regret is a feeling. Repentance is a direction.
Peter failed the same night. He swore three times that he did not know Jesus. Then Luke says “the Lord turned and looked straight at Peter,” and Peter “went outside and wept bitterly” (Luke 22:61 to 62). He stayed near the others, and the risen Jesus found him by the Sea of Galilee. Jesus had already told him, “when you have turned back, strengthen your brothers” (Luke 22:32). The full story is in why Peter denied Jesus.
Paul names the difference: “Godly sorrow brings repentance that leads to salvation and leaves no regret, but worldly sorrow brings death” (2 Corinthians 7:10). Judas had sorrow, but never the turn toward Jesus that makes sorrow godly. That is why repentance in the Bible is not a feeling you work up. It is coming home.
Judas and Peter both felt terrible. One took his guilt to people who could not help him. The other let Jesus find him.
Matthew and Acts describe the end of Judas's life differently, and skeptics call it a contradiction. Here is the short answer. The longer one is in how Judas died.
Judas throws the silver into the temple, leaves, and takes his own life. The priests will not put blood money back in the treasury, so they use it to buy the potter's field as a burial place for foreigners.
Luke says the field was acquired with the reward of his wickedness and that Judas fell there. Jerusalem came to call it Akeldama, the Field of Blood.
Both agree on the money, the field, the name and a sudden end. The priests bought the field with his money, so Luke can say he acquired it. One long-held harmonization reads Luke as describing what happened afterward. Either way, it is two writers telling one death for two purposes.
Neither lingers, and neither uses the manner of his death to explain his fate. Matthew cares about the blood money and the Scripture it fulfilled. Luke cares about the empty seat among the Twelve.
If reading about his death stirs something painful in you, please stop and reach out. The 988 line is open right now, by call or text, and so is our door.
The hardest part of the Judas story is not the verdict. It is how close he was.
John 13 says Jesus knew exactly who would betray Him, and then He knelt and washed the disciples' feet, every one of them, including Judas (see why Jesus washed their feet). He handed Judas the bread. In the garden He called him friend. Jesus is the clearest picture of the Father we have, and that picture is a God who kept the door open for the man walking out of it.
Judas walked out anyway. That is what perishing looks like in the Bible. Not God slamming a door, but a person refusing the only door there is.
So this story is not a warning about how people die. It is an invitation about how to live. If you think something you did puts you in the Judas category, you are not Judas unless you walk away. Peter failed that same night, and seven weeks later he was preaching to thousands. Turn toward Jesus and let Him find you. If you are not sure how, start with how to repent to God.
For related reading, see what forgiveness is, the significance of the Last Supper, who Satan is and what we believe at Sound of Heaven.
Judas perished because he betrayed and rejected Jesus, not because of how he died, and the same Jesus who called him friend still welcomes anyone who turns back.
If you are struggling with thoughts of ending your life, call or text 988 now. If you have lost someone to suicide, hear it one more time: how a person dies does not decide their eternity, and a believer who dies by suicide is with the Lord.
Talk to a pastor. Send us your prayer need or plan a visit and sit with us in person. Or use the form just below, and someone from Sound of Heaven will pray with you this week.
Guilt, grief, or a question you have been afraid to ask. Tell us, and someone at Sound of Heaven will pray with you.
No. Jesus Himself answered the question. In John 17:12 He said none of His followers had been lost except the one doomed to destruction, and in Matthew 26:24 He said it would have been better for Judas if he had never been born. Both statements came while Judas was still alive, so the reason was his betrayal and rejection of Jesus, not the way he died. Read with the rest of Scripture, Judas perished. He was not sent somewhere to suffer forever.
No. Scripture never calls suicide the unforgivable sin, and the Judas story does not teach that it is. Jesus spoke about Judas's fate before Judas died. Salvation rests on what Jesus did and on whether a person belongs to Him, and Jesus said no one will snatch His sheep out of His hand. A believer who dies by suicide is with the Lord. If you are struggling right now, call or text 988 in the US, and reach out to a pastor.
It is an older translation of a phrase in John 17:12 that literally reads son of destruction. In biblical idiom, a son of something is a person marked by it, the way James and John were called sons of thunder. The Greek word apōleia means destruction or ruin, and it belongs with the verb for perish in John 3:16. Jesus was saying Judas was headed for destruction, the loss of life, not endless torment.
Matthew 27:3 says he was seized with remorse, returned the silver and said he had sinned. That is real regret, but the Gospels never show him turning toward Jesus. He took his confession to the chief priests, who sent him away. Peter failed the same night and turned back, and Jesus restored him. Paul describes the difference in 2 Corinthians 7:10: godly sorrow brings repentance that leads to salvation, while worldly sorrow brings death.
Yes. Nothing Judas did was beyond the reach of the cross. Jesus washed his feet, shared bread with him and called him friend in the garden, and the same grace that restored Peter was there for Judas. What Scripture shows is not a door God closed but a door Judas refused to walk through. That is why his story is an invitation for the rest of us. Whatever you have done, turning to Jesus is still open to you today.