Bible Study · From The Scapegoat To Matthias

Casting Lots In The Bible: What It Meant

Israel handed hard decisions to God with a handful of stones. The church did it one last time, days before Pentecost, and then never again. Here is why that matters for how you decide things now.

By Pastor Johnny Ova · Sound of Heaven · 10 Min Read

The Short Answer

A Decision Handed Back To God

Straight Answer

Casting lots in the Bible meant making a decision by shaking out a marked stone or stick and receiving the result from God. Israel used it to choose the scapegoat, divide the land and assign temple duties, and the church used it one last time to choose Matthias, just before the Spirit was poured out at Pentecost.

After Acts 2 the lot disappears. The church kept making hard decisions. It made them through prayer, Scripture, the voice of the Spirit and the wisdom of the community.

That shift is the whole story, and it answers the question most people are really asking, which is whether a coin flip can tell you God’s will. We will get there. First, what a lot actually was.

The Word

What A Lot Actually Was

The Hebrew word is goral. It covers both the object and what the object gave you. The lexicons describe it as a small stone used for deciding questions, and by extension a person’s portion, share or destiny.

HebrewGoralגּוֹרָל77 Uses

The object

A pebble or a marked piece of wood. Later Jewish sources remember lots made of black and white pebbles, and of olive, nut or cypress wood.

The method

The stones went into the fold of a garment or into a vessel and were shaken until one came out. That is the picture behind “into the lap” in Proverbs 16:33.

The result

What the lot gave you was your portion. That is why Psalm 16:5 can say to God, “you alone are my portion and my cup; you make my lot secure.”

The Greek

The New Testament word is klēros, with the same range: the lot itself, and the share it assigns. Luke uses it for the lot that fell on Matthias and for the share of ministry Judas walked away from.

The Jewish Encyclopedia puts it neatly: the Hebrew word “has retained the meaning of ‘share’; it has also acquired the more general meaning of ‘fate’.” A lot was never only a tool. It was the thing that told you where you belonged.

“The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD.”

Proverbs 16:33

That verse is the theology underneath the practice. Israel did not think the stones were clever. They believed God stood behind the outcome of an act they had deliberately placed in his hands. The chapter around it has a lot to say about plans and outcomes, which we worked through in Proverbs 16:3.

Takeaway

A lot was a pebble and a portion. Israel trusted the portion to God, never the pebble.

The Story

Where The Lot Shows Up

Lots appear across the whole sweep of Scripture, from the tabernacle to the upper room. Walk through the major scenes and a pattern shows up.

Leviticus 16

The Two Goats

On the Day of Atonement the high priest cast lots over two goats. One lot fell for the LORD and that goat became a sin offering. The other marked the scapegoat, sent alive into the wilderness carrying the people’s sins. Aaron did not get to pick.

Joshua 18

The Land

“Joshua then cast lots for them in Shiloh in the presence of the LORD,” and divided the land. Every tribe received its territory the same way, so nobody could say Joshua had played favorites with the best land.

1 Chronicles 24

The Priests

David’s priestly divisions were assigned by lot. Centuries later Zechariah, the father of John the Baptist, “was chosen by lot, according to the custom of the priesthood,” to burn incense in the temple (Luke 1:9).

Jonah 1

The Ship

Pagan sailors in a storm cast lots to find out who was responsible, “and the lot fell on Jonah.” God met them inside their own method, and by the end of the chapter they are offering sacrifices to the LORD.

Esther 3 And 9

The Pur

Haman “cast the pur (that is, the lot)” to pick a date to destroy the Jews. The date he rolled became the date of their rescue, and the feast still carries the name: Purim. God is never named in Esther, and this is one of the quiet places he shows up anyway.

John 19

The Cross

Roman soldiers cast lots for the clothes of Jesus, and John hears Psalm 22 being fulfilled.

Acts 1

Matthias

The apostles cast lots to fill the place Judas left. It is the last time believers use a lot anywhere in Scripture.

Priests, a general, pagan sailors, a would be mass murderer and Roman soldiers all cast lots. What set Israel apart was the setting: before the LORD, with the result received as his. The high priest also carried the Urim and Thummim, whose mechanics Scripture never explains.

Secure · One-Time, Weekly Or Monthly generosity is worship

Give Now.

Every post here is free to read. If this one helped you, you can help keep it that way. Pick an amount and finish on Stripe's secure checkout.

One-Time

Weekly

Monthly

Choose an amount

$25

$50

$100

$250

$500

Give $100

Secure checkout by Stripe Card, Apple Pay and Link Receipt emailed to you

Already Give Weekly Or Monthly?

Change your amount, update your card, or cancel anytime. Enter the email you give with and Stripe sends you a secure link.

Manage My Giving

"Each of you should give what you have decided in your heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver."2 Corinthians 9:7

The Cross

Soldiers Rolling For A Robe

“Let’s not tear it,” they said to one another. “Let’s decide by lot who will get it.” This happened that the scripture might be fulfilled that said, “They divided my clothes among them and cast lots for my garment.”

John 19:24

Four soldiers split the clothes into four shares, but the undergarment was seamless, woven in one piece. So they drew lots for it at the foot of the cross.

John sees Psalm 22:18 in that moment. It is the same psalm that opens with “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?”, the cry Jesus prays from the cross. John wants you to hear the whole psalm, a sufferer stripped and mocked who ends up praising God in the assembly. It is a small detail pointing at the large story of why Jesus was crucified.

The Claim

The soldiers gambled at the cross, so gambling is wicked. Or the reverse: lots are pagan, and this scene proves it.

What The Text Shows

The soldiers are described, not held up as an example of anything. They were splitting spoils the cheapest way they could. John’s point is the psalm, not the method.

The same act is holy at Shiloh and callous at Golgotha. The difference was never the stones. It was the heart of the people holding them. A lot was a way of making a decision, not a way of winning money, which is why it settles nothing about whether gambling is a sin.

The Last Lot

Matthias And The Day Everything Changed

Jesus has ascended. The Spirit has not yet come. About a hundred and twenty believers are meeting constantly in prayer, and Peter says the place Judas left must be filled.

He sets a standard first. The man must have been with them “beginning from John’s baptism to the time when Jesus was taken up from us,” a witness of the resurrection. Two men fit. The church nominates both, then prays: “Lord, you know everyone’s heart. Show us which of these two you have chosen.”

“Then they cast lots, and the lot fell to Matthias; so he was added to the eleven apostles.”

Acts 1:26

Look at the order. Criteria drawn from Jesus’ own ministry, a shortlist made by the community, prayer, and only then a lot to choose between two equally qualified men. The lot did not replace discernment. It came at the very end of it.

Was Matthias A Mistake?

A popular sermon line says the apostles jumped ahead of God and his real twelfth apostle was Paul. At its strongest: Matthias is never mentioned again, and Paul clearly became an apostle. That is an argument from silence. Most of the Twelve are never mentioned again either. Luke gives no hint of disapproval, and in Acts 6:2 he writes that “the Twelve gathered all the disciples together,” counting Matthias among them. Paul also never met the standard in Acts 1:22. Good sermon point, bad history.

Then came the Day of Pentecost. The Spirit was poured out on every believer in the room, and from that day the lot never appears again. Watch how the church decides things afterwards.

Acts 6

The church needs seven men to serve tables. The community chooses them for their character, looking for people full of the Spirit and wisdom. No lot.

Acts 13:2

“While they were worshiping the Lord and fasting, the Holy Spirit said, ‘Set apart for me Barnabas and Saul for the work to which I have called them.’” Guidance arrives in worship.

Acts 15:28

After a long, heated council the leaders write, “It seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us.” Spirit and community decide together.

Acts 16:6 to 10

Paul’s team is kept from two regions by the Spirit, then a vision in the night redirects them to Macedonia. Closed doors and fresh direction, still no lot.

Takeaway

The last lot in the Bible falls days before Pentecost. That is the hinge. Once the Spirit lives in every believer, the church stops asking the stones.

Today

Should Christians Cast Lots Today?

Scripture never forbids the lot. Deuteronomy 18 forbids divination, reading omens to pry out hidden knowledge, and Israel’s lot was commanded in the Law and used before the LORD. So this is a question of wisdom, and sincere Christians land in different places.

View One: Never, It Is Divination

At its strongest: asking chance for God’s verdict looks like what the prophets condemned. The weakness is that it condemns a practice God himself gave Israel.

View Two: Still Valid For Big Decisions

At its strongest: Proverbs 16:33 is still in the Bible, and the apostles did it. The Moravians under Zinzendorf used the lot to choose elders, confirm missionaries and even decide marriage partners, as Christian History records. The weakness is that it ignores where Acts goes after chapter 1.

View Three: Fine For Fairness, Not For Guidance

A coin toss to settle who goes first, or between two good options, is a fair tie break, not a word from God. This is where we land.

Where We Stand, Plainly

Our position at Sound of Heaven is this. Since Pentecost, God guides his people by the Spirit, through Scripture read in the light of Jesus, and through the wisdom of a praying community. That is the pattern of Acts, and it is how we make decisions now.

Flipping a coin to pick a restaurant is not a sin. What is wrong is treating a coin, a Bible opened at random or a fleece as a verdict that overrides wisdom, counsel and the Spirit’s leading. That turns chance into divination, and it gets used most on anxious believers who are terrified of missing some hidden perfect plan.

The error on the other side is just as real. Some Christians talk as though God no longer guides anyone beyond the printed page. That is also wrong. Jesus promised that the Spirit of truth “will guide you into all the truth,” and he still speaks, often in the still small voice rather than the storm.

When does the Bible last record believers casting lots?

When Joshua divided the land at Shiloh

When the apostles chose Matthias, before Pentecost

When the church in Antioch sent out Barnabas and Saul

Acts 1:26 is the last lot. In Acts 13 the Holy Spirit speaks during worship and fasting, and the church sends Barnabas and Saul on that word, with no lot involved.

Where This Lands

The Lot Has Already Fallen

Every lot in Israel rested on a hope: that God would decide, and that the portion would be good. “The boundary lines have fallen for me in pleasant places,” the psalmist sang.

In Jesus that hope was answered in full. Paul tells the Colossians that the Father has qualified us to share in the inheritance of his people in the kingdom of light. The word behind that inheritance is klēros, the same word as the lot. The lot has fallen, and it fell to you. The Kingdom is here, the Spirit lives in you, and you do not need a stone in your lap to know you belong to him.

So pray, read, ask people who love Jesus, and then move. You are being led. For related reading, see what the will of God is, discernment in the Bible, the role of the Holy Spirit and the sign of Jonah, or come and visit us.

The Whole Thing In One Line

Casting lots was Israel’s way of handing a decision to God, used from the scapegoat to Matthias and never again after Pentecost, because the Spirit who now lives in every believer guides the church through Scripture, prayer and shared wisdom.

Stuck Between Two Good Options?

Tell us what you are weighing. Someone at Sound of Heaven will pray it through with you, no coin required.

Questions People Ask

Questions About Casting Lots

What does casting lots mean in the Bible?

Casting lots meant making a decision by shaking or drawing a marked stone or piece of wood and accepting the result as God’s. The Hebrew word, goral, means both the lot and the portion it assigned. Israel used lots to choose the scapegoat on the Day of Atonement, divide the land under Joshua and assign priestly duties. Proverbs 16:33 gives the belief behind it: the lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD.

Is casting lots the same as gambling?

No. A lot was a way of making a decision, not a way of winning money. Nobody staked anything, and the point was to take a choice out of human hands, which is close to the opposite of what a casino is for. Even the soldiers at the cross were dividing spoils, not placing bets. The Bible’s lots do not settle the gambling question in either direction, so that question has to be answered from other principles.

Why did the apostles cast lots for Matthias?

They needed to replace Judas and restore the Twelve. Peter set a standard, someone who had been with Jesus from John’s baptism to the ascension, and two men qualified. The church prayed and then cast lots between them, following a practice every Jew knew from the temple. It happened before Pentecost. Once the Spirit was poured out in Acts 2, the church never used a lot again, and made decisions through prayer, the Spirit’s leading and shared counsel.

Is it a sin for Christians to flip a coin to make a decision?

Flipping a coin to break a tie or settle something small is not a sin. It becomes a problem when a coin, a random Bible verse or a fleece is treated as God’s verdict, overriding wisdom, counsel and the Spirit’s leading. That treats chance as divination. Since Pentecost, God guides believers by his Spirit, through Scripture read in the light of Jesus and through a praying community. A coin can be a fair tie break. It is not a word from God.

Why did the soldiers cast lots for Jesus’ clothes?

The four soldiers split Jesus’ garments into four shares, but his undergarment was seamless, woven in one piece, so rather than tear it they drew lots for it. John 19:24 says this fulfilled the scripture in Psalm 22:18, quoting it as “They divided my clothes among them and cast lots for my garment.” John is pointing readers to the whole of Psalm 22, which begins with the cry Jesus prayed from the cross.